The concept of the circular economy is gaining traction at the local level but many local governments struggle to find concrete entry points for action. The management of circular economy projects often clashes with the sectoral manner in which administrations and industries are organized. But many industrial legacy cities are focusing on fairness in their sustainable urban transition – aiming to rectify the fact that certain communities were previously overlooked. Through a focus on circular economy, these industrial legacy cities are prioritizing the redistribution of resources based on equity.
Today, these imaginations and challenges are rapidly put into actions in cities and manifested through diverse practices on the ground. To open this discussion to wider practitioners, Urban Transitions Alliance cities Baltimore, Beijing E-Town and Turku, together with the city of Panaji, participated in the World Circular Economy Forum organized by Finland and the Finnish innovation fund Sitra. This year, the Forum aimed to demonstrate how the circular economy could enhance resilience on a business and society level. This online side event, hosted by the city of Turku and ICLEI, placed a special focus on how cities put circular economy into practice in collaboration with stakeholders.
The journey toward circularity
Circular development can be seen like a journey with five progressive stages: Recover, Reduce, Reuse, Redesign and Regenerate. This circular journey is inspired by ICLEI’s engagement with cities around the world. Simply put, the 5Rs support cities in implementing good waste management and resource efficiency in industries, while facilitating circular business models and finally embedding circularity into the urban metabolism. At the same time, it helps a city to map out their current position of the journey toward circularity, and to identify peer cities and partners for collaboration. The following stories from the city panelists seemly corresponded to different stages of such a journey.
Circular stories from Panaji, Beijing, Baltimore and Turku
Panaji, 100% landfill-free. The capital of Goa shared their circular economy strategy for the waste management program with the goal to be 100% landfill-free. The city has set up 100+ compost stations on the community level. Biogas stations are planned to handle larger waste volumes from restaurants and other commercial entities, reintroducing the biogas back to the businesses. As for dry waste, the city has devised 16 categories of recycling, and non-recyclables are sent to the cement plant for co-incineration.
Beijing E-Town, Zero Waste City. As one of the 16 zero-waste pilot cities and districts in China, Beijing E-Town is developing a roadmap to control the increase of high-tech industrial solid waste, completely utilize agricultural waste, and prohibit illegal dumping of solid waste. Their “market-oriented method” is a key collaborative method through which district managers interact with investors. With comprehensive infrastructure and environmental policy E-Town attracts energy-saving and environmentally friendly high-tech industries.
Baltimore, Waste to Wealth Program. The program re-thinks three of the city’s largest waste streams – construction, wood and food wastes. The value from these waste streams is recaptured, new jobs and products are created, and neighborhoods are revitalized. For example, the deconstruction program in Baltimore doesn’t use traditional demolition techniques;, instead the program deconstructs vacant houses in Baltimore brick by brick or, board by board. The precious materials are then restored, along with their value. This initiative has grown into a 4 million-dollar business, and created 6 to 8 times more jobs than the normal demolishing process.
Turku, Circular Turku Project. The city emphasizes their efforts on the engagement with private and academic sectors. Bastu is a business enabler for entrepreneurs and businesses in the Turku region. This enabler collaborates with the University of Turku and business on circular innovation to tap into the growing market of circular business. The Telaketju project was held by the Turku University of Applied Sciences and Lounais-Suomen Jätehuolto, a regional waste management company. The project includes developing the collection, sorting, and refining processes of end-of-life textiles.
Taking the people with you on this journey
Stories reported from the cities shared with the participants how they’ve put the circular economy concept into action. Each case has discovered its way to deviate from resource-intensive businesses and transform them into circular practices. Interestingly, each story has its way of outreach and engages with the people. In Panaji, citizen engagement starts early in the schools. Through the education system, the city of Panaji engages the citizens with their new waste management policy. Beijing E-Town focuses on building its partnerships with high-tech industries. Baltimore takes care of the minority groups, while Turku incubates its future circular start-ups. We often found citizen-engagement is also part of the creative circular idea. We saw in Baltimore, for example, how their circular food initiative has identified, trained, and collaborated with the ‘Ambassadors’, usually passionate residents, encouraging them to reach out to their communities.
We like to invite city practitioners around the world to share their stories, challenges, and questions about their journey towards circularity. Please join ICLEI Circulars and contact us circular.development(at)iclei.org